Maui Domestic Violence Victim Had TRO Against Abuser


No More - campaign to end domestic violence and sexual assault

No More – campaign to end domestic violence and sexual assault

A Maui woman was fatally stabbed by her estranged husband in a Wailuku supermarket on Tuesday, as reported by KHON2.  The crime was made worse by the fact that the victim/wife had already obtained a domestic violence Order for Protection against her husband just last Wednesday in the Maui Family Court.

Per Court records, the victim, 24 year old Kehau Farias Schmidt had filed for a TRO against her husband, 45 year old Stephen B. Schmidt on March 31, 2016.  The Ex Parte Petition for TRO was granted that day, and served the same day upon her husband.  The parties appeared at Family Court in Wailuku on April 13, 2016, where the Court ordered a one year Order for Protection against the husband, and also directed him to domestic violence classes.  Despite this, on April 19, 2016, Schmidt allegedly engaged in contact with his wife and a man accompanying her, leading to her fatal stabbing.  Thereafter, Schmidt allegedly stabbed two other men at the store who had attempted to intervene.

The murder occurring despite the existence of a protective order is a terrifying thought for other domestic violence victims seeking protection from their abuser.  However, rather than simply seeing a TRO/protective order as being useless, it should highlight what lawyers in the domestic violence field so often tell their clients:  an order for protection is only a piece of paper.  We do not tell victims this in order to dissuade them from seeking help.  Instead, we underline that the TRO process is only as strong as their abuser’s fear of going to jail.  Abusers who do not fear going to jail, or those that feel that they have nothing to lose, are the most dangerous and may not be deterred by a TRO.  Thus, a safety plan is strongly encouraged.  A safety plan is an individual plan for a victim of how to be safe – where to go, what immediate and long terms steps to take, who to inform about the situation (family, friends, co-workers, other authorities).  The National Domestic Violence Hotline has a good outline of safety planning.

Applying for a TRO and Order for Protection are good steps for a domestic violence victim.  But it needs to be supported by good planning and additional safety steps.

Some DV resources for victims seeking help:

These are just a few of the many places to seek assistance.  Those in emergency situations should call 911, and seek further help from these resources along with family and friends.


About Gavin K. Doi

Gavin, a founding partner of Doi/Luke, was born and reared in Honolulu, Hawai‘i, graduating from McKinley High School, and receiving his Bachelor of Arts in Political Science from Reed College in Portland, Oregon. He received his Juris Doctorate from the University of Denver College of Law in Denver, Colorado. Previously, Gavin worked with the Child Support Enforcement Agency and the AmeriCorps Domestic Violence Clinic. An advocate of pro bono legal work, Gavin volunteers time with Volunteer Legal Services Hawaii and the Hawai’i State Bar Association.In 2013, Gavin co-authored the book Child Custody Litigation and Settlements (Aspatore Books/Thomson West), penning the section "Working with Your Client Towards a Successful Child Custody Case." Gavin is a member of the Hawaii State Bar Association and the HSBA Family Law Section, and was presented with the 2002 Justice Award by the Hawaii State Bar Association, which honors one lawyer annually for their outstanding contribution to the ideals of justice. The Hawaii Access to Justice Commission honored Gavin in 2012 for his pro bono service to the community.Gavin has extensive experience in divorce, paternity, child custody, child support, restraining orders, and other family law matters, and has a Distinguished rating with Martindale-Hubble®/Lawyers.com, and an Avvo rating of 10 out of 10. He can be e-mailed at: gkdoi@islandlawyers.com .